The
nature of science is based on the importance of experimentation as scientific
discovery is continuously evolving. As opposed to math which is characterized
by concrete laws, science is based on experimentation by which fluctuations
will exist in the theories and conclusions that result from experimentation.
The Ontario Curriculum states that “scientists continuously assess and judge
the soundness of scientific knowledge claims by testing laws and theories and
modifying them in light of compelling new evidence or a re-conceptualization of
existing evidence.” The question becomes: how does the role of scientists
determine what teachers expect of their students in terms of an approach to
science? The answer to this question requires the teacher and student to
address this question from two different perspectives.
The first
perspective is that of inquisitiveness, experimentation, and, most
significantly, the realization that all theories can and should be re-evaluated
based on the existence of new knowledge. Therefore, the student can not only
strive for this new knowledge but can use this knowledge in combination with
experimentation to pursue new theories. However, this perspective only
represents half of the student’s responsibility in relation to questioning and
experimentation.
Experimentation
is a vital endeavour but without weighing the risks/rewards of the possible
products which can result from creating a new scientific theory the results can
be potentially dangerous. Robert Oppenheimer, the scientific director of the
Manhattan Project, was a major contributor to the development of the world’s
first atomic bomb and the subsequent destruction of Hiroshima and Nagasaki. He
is quoted as saying "Now I am become death, the destroyer of worlds."
The probability that this technology resulting from the science would be
destructive should make the scientist question whether or not this science
should have been pursued. It is necessary that all science students approach any
research with the realization of the risks involved.